Product Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray Review: A Practical Oven Air-Frying Option

A two-piece oven crisper set for cooks who want to air-fry, roast, or reheat smaller portions without adding a countertop appliance.

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

For cooks comparing gotham steel air fryer reviews, the Gotham Steel Crisper Tray offers an oven-based way to crisp foods using a raised mesh basket and a solid catch pan.

Its appeal depends on having a compatible oven and preferring a simple two-piece accessory over a separate appliance.

Gotham Steel Tray Review Summary

The quick verdict

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A two-piece oven crisper set for cooks who want to air-fry, roast, or reheat smaller portions without adding a countertop appliance.

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid catch pan.
  • Round tray and basket measure 13.12 inches across, according to the product dimensions.
  • Copper-colored Gotham Steel Ti Cerama nonstick coating covers the cooking tray and basket.
  • Aluminum-core construction with a titanium and ceramic nonstick finish.

Pros

  • Elevated mesh design leaves space for air to move around food.
  • The lower pan helps contain drips and crumbs instead of letting them fall directly onto the oven.

Consider before buying

  • The 13.12-inch round footprint may not fit every compact oven or rack; measure the available space before buying.
  • Cooking depends on an oven with an appropriate air-fry or convection setting, so it is not a stand-alone countertop air fryer.
Read the full review summary

The set pairs a copper-colored, nonstick-coated aluminum pan with a raised mesh basket. The open basket is designed to let hot air circulate around food, while the pan underneath catches grease and crumbs.

Together, they create a compact setup for air-frying, baking, roasting, or reheating in an oven or convection oven.

This is best suited to people who already have an oven with an air-fry or convection mode and want a dedicated tray for smaller batches.

Its round form and stated 13.12-inch diameter make checking oven-rack clearance important, especially in compact ovens. The two-piece design keeps the setup straightforward, though it does not replace the capacity or dedicated controls of a separate appliance.

The buying factors

Gotham Steel Tray Scorecard

Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.

8/10

Oven versatility

The tray is intended for air-frying, baking, roasting, and reheating, making it useful beyond one cooking mode.

8/10

Airflow-focused design

The raised mesh basket separates food from the pan and is designed to promote circulation around it.

8/10

Grease and crumb capture

A solid tray beneath the basket catches drips and crumbs during cooking.

8/10

Cleanup convenience

The nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe construction can simplify cleanup.

6/10

Fit flexibility

It is described as fitting many standard racks and smaller convection ovens, but buyers should verify the round tray's dimensions against their oven.

7/10

Material and coating appeal

The aluminum core and titanium-ceramic nonstick coating offer a lightweight cooking surface, with the coating described as free of PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.

Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Tray

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid catch pan.
  • Round tray and basket measure 13.12 inches across, according to the product dimensions.
  • Copper-colored Gotham Steel Ti Cerama nonstick coating covers the cooking tray and basket.
  • Aluminum-core construction with a titanium and ceramic nonstick finish.
  • Dishwasher-safe construction for cleaning after cooking.
  • Designed for oven air-fry, convection, bake, roast, and reheat settings.
  • The solid pan sits below the basket to collect grease and crumbs.

Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Tray

Pros

  • Elevated mesh design leaves space for air to move around food.
  • The lower pan helps contain drips and crumbs instead of letting them fall directly onto the oven.
  • One set supports several oven cooking tasks, including air-frying, roasting, and reheating.
  • Nonstick surfaces and dishwasher-safe construction are convenient for routine cleanup.

Consider before buying

  • The 13.12-inch round footprint may not fit every compact oven or rack; measure the available space before buying.
  • Cooking depends on an oven with an appropriate air-fry or convection setting, so it is not a stand-alone countertop air fryer.
  • The circular basket may use rack space differently from a rectangular sheet pan, which matters if you often cook multiple trays at once.

Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Tray?

Good fit

Consider this tray if you want to try oven air-frying without adding another appliance to the counter.

The raised basket and drip-catching pan make sense for foods that benefit from exposure to circulating air while keeping some mess contained below.

It can also serve as a roasting or reheating surface when you want one accessory to cover several oven jobs.

Before ordering, measure the oven rack and check the clearance around the tray, particularly if your oven is small or has unusually shaped racks.

Also consider your typical batch size: this is a single round basket-and-pan set, so it is most appealing for modest portions rather than large, multi-item meals.

Who should skip it

Skip it if you need an appliance that operates independently of your oven or offers its own controls. This is an oven accessory, and its intended use relies on your oven's available cooking modes.

Look elsewhere if the round 13.12-inch dimensions do not suit your rack layout or if your routine depends on fitting several large portions across a broad rectangular surface.

How the Gotham Steel Tray Fits an Oven Air-Frying Routine

Raised basket, separate catch pan

The basket's elevated mesh is the central design choice: food sits above the solid pan rather than directly on it.

That arrangement is intended to expose more of the food to circulating oven air, while the pan provides a place for grease and crumbs to collect.

It is a practical combination for cooks who want the airflow-oriented setup and a catch surface in one accessory.

Check the round footprint first

The stated 13.12-inch diameter gives a useful starting point, but rack width alone is not the only fit consideration.

Measure the rack's usable area and account for any oven walls, rails, or neighboring cookware that could interfere with placing or removing a round tray. This is especially relevant for smaller convection ovens.

A coating built around easier release

The tray and basket use a copper-colored titanium-ceramic nonstick finish. That design is intended to ease food release and cleanup, and the set is described as dishwasher-safe.

Buyers who prefer to protect coated cookware can check the care guidance that comes with the product and use utensils and cleaning methods suitable for a nonstick surface.

An accessory, not a separate cooker

The tray can support air-frying, baking, roasting, or reheating, but it works within the oven's cooking modes. That makes it a reasonable space-saving option for an oven owner who wants a dedicated crisper setup.

Someone who wants a separate cooking station or appliance-specific controls should compare standalone options instead.

Alternatives to Gotham Steel Tray

Grill Baskets alternative

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
4.6/5

700+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket

Choose the Gotham Steel set for an oven-centered crisper routine and its included catch pan. Consider the Cave Tools basket if your priority is cooking small foods over an outdoor grill and you want a handled stainless-steel basket.

  • The Cave Tools basket is a dishwasher-safe stainless-steel grill pan with a curved handle, designed to keep small foods such as vegetables, shrimp, fish, and fruit from falling through grill grates.
  • The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven use and combines a raised basket with a solid pan that catches drips and crumbs.

Grill Baskets alternative

Kona Smoker & Grill Basket
4.3/5

200+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Kona Smoker & Grill Basket

The Gotham Steel set fits cooks looking for an oven accessory with a drip pan.

The Kona is a better fit when the job is holding small ingredients on a barbecue grill or in a smoker; the products serve different cooking environments.

  • The Kona is a 12-by-12-inch mesh grill basket intended for outdoor grilling and cold smoking.
  • Its mesh is designed to keep small foods from falling through grill grates, and the product is described as dishwasher-safe.
  • The Gotham Steel tray pairs a mesh basket with a solid pan for oven air-frying and other oven cooking modes.

Is Gotham Steel Tray Worth It?

The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if you already use an oven's air-fry or convection mode and want a coated mesh basket with a catch pan for smaller batches.

Its multi-use design and dishwasher-safe construction make it a practical oven accessory.

Measure your oven before buying, since the round 13.12-inch footprint may be awkward in some compact layouts. If you want independent appliance controls or outdoor grilling capability, this tray does not match that need.

Your review at a glance

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A two-piece oven crisper set for cooks who want to air-fry, roast, or reheat smaller portions without adding a countertop appliance.

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid catch pan.
  • Round tray and basket measure 13.12 inches across, according to the product dimensions.
  • Copper-colored Gotham Steel Ti Cerama nonstick coating covers the cooking tray and basket.
  • Aluminum-core construction with a titanium and ceramic nonstick finish.

Written by

yupfoodie.com Editorial Team

Editorial team

yupfoodie.com publishes practical how-to guides and educational articles with clear steps and useful context.

Amazon customer reviews

See what buyers think

Explore customer reviews, photos and available video reviews on Amazon.

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A two-piece oven crisper set for cooks who want to air-fry, roast, or reheat smaller portions without adding a countertop appliance.

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid catch pan.
  • Round tray and basket measure 13.12 inches across, according to the product dimensions.
Check Video Reviews on Amazon